Nov 11, 2026

Should I choose an electric shower or a mixer shower?

How electric and mixer showers work, which one suits your hot water system, and what to check before you choose.

Should I choose an electric shower or a mixer shower?

The right choice between an electric shower and a mixer shower depends mostly on your hot water system. An electric shower makes its own hot water, so it suits homes where hot water is limited or a second shower is needed. A mixer shower blends hot and cold from your boiler or cylinder, so it suits homes with a combi boiler or a good stored supply.

This post explains how each type works, which homes each one suits, and the simple checks you can make before you decide. You can look at your boiler, cylinder and consumer unit (fuse box) safely, but the wiring and pipework behind a shower are always a job for a qualified person.

How an electric shower works

An electric shower takes cold water from the mains and heats it as it passes through an element inside the unit, a bit like a kettle that only heats what you use. It doesn't need your boiler, so you still have a hot shower if the boiler breaks down.

Electric showers are rated in kilowatts (kW), a measure of how much power they use. Most are between about 7.5kW and 10.8kW. The higher the rating, the more water the unit can heat at once, and the better the flow at a comfortable temperature.

Because it heats water from cold, the flow is gentler than many mixer showers, and it drops in winter when the incoming water is colder.

How a mixer shower works

A mixer shower takes hot water from your boiler or hot water cylinder and cold water from your supply, then blends them in a valve to the temperature you set. Most new mixer showers are thermostatic, which means the valve holds the temperature steady if someone turns on a tap or flushes a toilet elsewhere in the house.

How well a mixer shower performs depends on the system feeding it:

  • Combi boiler: hot water comes straight from the mains, so pressure is usually good, but the flow is limited by your mains supply and the boiler's size.
  • Unvented cylinder: a sealed hot water tank fed by the mains, which gives some of the strongest showers. It needs a good mains supply and must be fitted and serviced by a qualified installer.
  • Gravity-fed system: a cold water tank in the loft feeds a cylinder in the airing cupboard. Pressure depends on how high the tank sits, so showers can be weak without a pump.

Which suits your home

An electric shower is often the better choice if:

  • you have a gravity-fed system with low pressure and no room for a pump
  • you want a second shower, such as in an en-suite, that won't run your main hot water down
  • you want a shower that still works when the boiler is off or broken

A mixer shower is often the better choice if:

  • you have a combi boiler or an unvented cylinder that can supply plenty of hot water
  • you want a stronger flow, a large rainfall head or a separate handset
  • you are having a full bathroom refit, when the walls are open and the valve can be hidden neatly behind the tiles

Safe checks you can make at home

You can work out a lot without touching anything:

  1. Find out what hot water system you have. No hot water tank usually means a combi boiler. A cylinder in a cupboard with a cold tank in the loft means a gravity-fed system. A cylinder with no loft tank is likely to be unvented.
  2. Check your mains flow. Time how long the kitchen cold tap takes to fill a bucket of known size, then work out roughly how many litres a minute it gives. A weak result can limit both types of shower.
  3. Look at your consumer unit. Many have a label for the shower circuit. Note whether there is a test button marked RCD, a safety switch that cuts the power if current leaks to earth.

If your current shower is weak rather than broken, our post on why your shower pressure might be low covers the other causes to rule out first.

Wiring, pumps and the rules

An electric shower draws more power than almost anything else in a home, so it needs its own circuit from the consumer unit with cable thick enough to carry the load. Swapping a unit for a more powerful one can mean a thicker cable or a new circuit. Under Part P of the Building Regulations, a new circuit, or adding to a circuit in the space around a bath or shower, must be notified to building control or certified by a registered electrician.

Never open an electric shower or touch its wiring yourself. If you notice a burning smell, scorch marks, a pull-cord switch that feels warm, or power that keeps tripping when the shower runs, switch the shower off at the consumer unit and have it checked by an electrician.

Mixer showers on a gravity-fed system sometimes need a pump. A standard shower pump draws from a stored tank, and should never be added to a combi boiler or unvented cylinder unless the maker says it is designed for it. A pump or booster taking more than 12 litres a minute from the mains needs the water company's consent before it is fitted.

How hard water affects both types

Thames Water, which supplies much of south west London, says all the water in its region is hard. That leaves limescale, a chalky build-up, in shower heads, valves and the heater inside an electric shower.

You can soak the shower head in descaler to keep the flow even. Scale inside the heater or a mixer valve is a job for a plumber, as both must be isolated and taken apart safely.

What we look at before recommending a shower

When we plan a new shower, we start with a site visit. We check your hot water system, the water pressure and flow, and whether your consumer unit and wiring can take an electric shower. If your boiler can't keep up with the shower you want, our boiler installation service can look at whether a different system would suit you better.

If you are weighing up an electric or mixer shower for a new bathroom or en-suite, Riverside Construction Group can check your system and talk you through the options on a site visit. Find out more about our bathroom installation service and get in touch to arrange a visit.

‍

Contact us

Ready to transform your home?